Review topics: ["size","fit","look","shirt","quality","fabric","shape","piece","feel","neck","turtleneck","bra","everlane","layer","works","sweater","wear","top","proportions","made","staple"].
Reviews
I wanted to love this but I don’t!
"Super disappointed in this because I typically love Everlane. The shirt itself is very soft and comfortable, but there are two major drawbacks. One is that the white is very sheer - I can’t wear this by itself because my bra is visible! The other is that there’s no “give” in the neck. I really strain to get this on and off because the neck is so tight with no “give”, and after only 3 wears the neck is completely stretched out and gaping. I’m so disappointed because I normally love Everlane shirts and turtlenecks!"
— Chloe31 (2/5)
I wanted to love this but I don’t!
"Super disappointed in this because I typically love Everlane. The shirt itself is very soft and comfortable, but there are two major drawbacks. One is that the white is very sheer - I can’t wear this by itself because my bra is visible! The other is that there’s no “give” in the neck. I really strain to get this on and off because the neck is so tight with no “give”, and after only 3 wears the neck is completely stretched out and gaping. I’m so disappointed because I normally love Everlane shirts and turtlenecks!"
— Chloe31 (2/5)
Neck is super small with no stretch 😢
"I'm so sad that I had to donate all three of these as they were super small for their size, especially the neck, with no stretch (and I am tiny with a pencil neck). I'm guessing these were a bad batch as the feel of the material makes little sense. I don't think they should be on the shelf, but pulled entirely. Everlane is normally amazing, so this is painful to go through."
— Kristenkristen (1/5)
Neck is super small with no stretch 😢
"I'm so sad that I had to donate all three of these as they were super small for their size, especially the neck, with no stretch (and I am tiny with a pencil neck). I'm guessing these were a bad batch as the feel of the material makes little sense. I don't think they should be on the shelf, but pulled entirely. Everlane is normally amazing, so this is painful to go through."
— Kristenkristen (1/5)
Disappointed
"This shirt did not meet my expectations for Everlane quality. The fabric is tissue-thin, the neck is too tight, and the sleeves are way too short for the size. The ribbed turtleneck I also purchased in M fits way better in the body and sleeves than this shirt in a L. I gave it away to a petite friend, since it was final sale. This is not the experience I have had with other Everlane items, so I hope it's a fluke."
— Goldie19 (2/5)
Disappointed
"This shirt did not meet my expectations for Everlane quality. The fabric is tissue-thin, the neck is too tight, and the sleeves are way too short for the size. The ribbed turtleneck I also purchased in M fits way better in the body and sleeves than this shirt in a L. I gave it away to a petite friend, since it was final sale. This is not the experience I have had with other Everlane items, so I hope it's a fluke."
— Goldie19 (2/5)
Finally a turtleneck that doesn't swamp you!
"I bought two of these because the slim fit is so perfect. It is understated, not as bulky as most turtlenecks. On its own or under a sweater, it looks simple and classy. And it is soft and warm as well."
— Happy F. (5/5)
Love! Fitted but not too tight!
"I love this turtleneck. I’ve already worn it twice and I’ve only had it for a week. Don’t worry, I washed it in between! But I was a little worried when I first tried it on because it’s pretty fitted and doesn’t have a lot of extra fabric but it isn’t constricting for anything. It fits pretty comfortably. I would compare it to the tissue turtleneck from J. Crew And I think the sizing is pretty similar as J. Crew. Would definitely buy again in more colors! 5’2” and 107lbs for reference"
— CatsNConcerts (5/5)
Arrive with two small holes
"What a huge disappointment this order was. The shirt arrived with two holes at the very front, near the neck. On top of that, the shirt is very sheer. For the price I expected a little more quality."
— Johanna0938 (1/5)
So stylish and comfortable
"I absolutely love the way this turtleneck look on me and how comfortable it is. It’s a great staple piece for work! My only complaint is that the turtleneck part itself doesn’t stretch so it is a little hard to put on and off. However, it’s loose and not too tight once it’s one, it just gets stuck around my head."
— Mar K. (5/5)
